--- title: "Unsealed OpenAI emails bolster NYT copyright case" id: "11375" type: "post" slug: "openai-nyt-fair-use-paywall" published_at: "2026-09-22T12:01:00+00:00" modified_at: "2026-10-28T11:58:16+00:00" url: "https://mediacopilot.ai/openai-nyt-fair-use-paywall/" markdown_url: "https://mediacopilot.ai/openai-nyt-fair-use-paywall.md" excerpt: "Internal messages on substitution and paywalls give the Times fresh ammunition, while broader publisher leverage still depends on the court." taxonomy_category: - "News" taxonomy_post_tag: - "licensing" - "New York Times" - "Copyright" - "Lawsuit" - "openai" --- # Unsealed OpenAI emails bolster NYT copyright case Internal messages on substitution and paywalls give the Times fresh ammunition, while broader publisher leverage still depends on the court. ![Image](https://mediacopilot.ai/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/02b3d511-7090-439c-b209-26ee876b859c-400x225.png) Unsealed emails and testimony give The New York Times new material in its copyright case against OpenAI and Microsoft. (Credit: ChatGPT) Sep 22, 2026 By [The Copilot](https://mediacopilot.ai/author/thecopilot/) “Gazillions.” That is how executives described the money at stake in commercializing AI models, according to newly unsealed material in The New York Times’ copyright lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft. The same documents show OpenAI’s head of ChatGPT, Nick Turley, writing that publishers face an “existential threat” from AI products that are “largely substitutive.” The [filings](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.612697/gov.uscourts.nysd.612697.1587.1.pdf) , unsealed last week, give the Times new material. As a result, the Times can argue that the companies used journalism to build products that compete with publishers that produced it. Lawyers and licensing experts interviewed by [Digiday](https://digiday.com/media/paywall-violation-eviscerates-fair-use-defense-what-openai-nyt-twist-means-for-publishers/?utm_source=chatgpt.com) said the documents could strengthen the Times’ case, particularly on market harm — the fourth factor courts consider when deciding whether a use is fair. Moreover, Digiday reported that content was priced and exchanged between Microsoft and OpenAI. In addition, major AI companies have also signed licensing agreements with publishers. “The defendants’ own conduct establishes that the content has a market price,” David Buttle, founder of publisher licensing coalition Spur, told Digiday. [Are you an AI Agent? Read more here >](https://mediacopilot.ai/openai-nyt-fair-use-paywall.md) The filings also include testimony from Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella, who acknowledged that chatbots can provide information without requiring users to visit the underlying source. Furthermore, News/Media Alliance CEO Danielle Coffey said that testimony strengthens the Times’ argument that AI products can substitute for publisher content. Alan Chapell, founder of privacy and technology consulting firm Chapell and Associates, pointed to a different statement. Specifically, he cited Turley’s description of OpenAI’s products as substitutive. Chapell said that apparent admission would be “difficult to walk back” and “likely eviscerates the fair use defense.” That is his assessment, not a settled legal conclusion. Another lawyer told Digiday the documents are damaging but stop short of being a complete game-changer. The lawyer noted that courts have still treated some AI training as transformative. The filings also raise questions about paywalled material. Chapell said evidence of deliberate circumvention would create a more serious problem for OpenAI. The [Digital Millennium Copyright Act](https://www.copyright.gov/dmca/) prohibits certain forms of circumvention of technological measures that control access to copyrighted works. For publishers, any broader bargaining power remains conditional. Digiday reported that if the Times wins — particularly on substitution or paywall circumvention — publishers could gain more leverage in licensing negotiations. Additionally, more may turn to litigation. Media Copilot has separately tracked [more than a dozen publisher cases involving OpenAI](https://mediacopilot.ai/publisher-ai-lawsuits-openai-perplexity/?utm_source=chatgpt.com) . They have also noted a broader [push for statutory licensing](https://mediacopilot.ai/ai-pay-for-news-statutory-licensing/?utm_source=chatgpt.com) in Europe, Brazil and other jurisdictions. Importantly, those developments are separate from the evidence in the Times case. Both sides are now asking Judge Sidney Stein for summary judgment. More documents could still be unsealed as the case moves forward. For now, the emails strengthen the Times’ case. Whether they strengthen publishers’ leverage depends on what the court does next. Posts co-authored by The Copilot are drafted with AI and then carefully edited by Media Copilot editors. Our AI-assisted process allows us to bring more valuable content to our readers while preserving accuracy and quality. Contributors - [The Copilot](https://mediacopilot.ai/author/thecopilot/) : AuthorI'm a generative AI writer for The Media Copilot. I help author posts, and with the help of human editors, play a growing role in the site's content strategy. - [Romy Abu-Fadel](https://mediacopilot.ai/author/romy/) : EditorRomy Abu-Fadel is a journalist, researcher, and 2026 graduate of Georgetown University's Edmund A. Walsh School of Foreign Service. She covers artificial intelligence and its impacts on the media industry. Category: [News](https://mediacopilot.ai/category/news/) Tags:[licensing](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/licensing/) | [New York Times](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/new-york-times/) | [Copyright](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/copyright/) | [Lawsuit](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/lawsuit/) | [openai](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/openai/) Share this post: [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://mediacopilot.ai/openai-nyt-fair-use-paywall/&display=popup&ref=plugin&src=share_button) [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share?url=https://mediacopilot.ai/openai-nyt-fair-use-paywall/&text=Unsealed%20OpenAI%20emails%20bolster%20NYT%20copyright%20case) [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://mediacopilot.ai/openai-nyt-fair-use-paywall/) [Email](/cdn-cgi/l/email-protection#caf5b9bfa8a0afa9bef793a5bfb8eff8faacb8a3afa4aeeff8faa2abb9eff8fab9a2abb8afaeeff8faaba4eff8faabb8bea3a9a6afeff8fabda3bea2eff8fab3a5bfe4ece9faf9f2f1a8a5aeb3f79fa4b9afaba6afaeeff8fa85baafa48b83eff8faafa7aba3a6b9eff8faa8a5a6b9beafb8eff8fa84939eeff8faa9a5bab3b8a3ada2beeff8faa9abb9afeffa8eeffa8ba2bebebab9eff98beff88ceff88ca7afaea3aba9a5baa3a6a5bee4aba3eff88ca5baafa4aba3e7a4b3bee7acaba3b8e7bfb9afe7baabb3bdaba6a6eff88ceffa8eeffa8b)