---
title: "Why “traffic is dead” is the wrong story"
id: "13080"
type: "post"
slug: "why-traffic-is-dead-is-the-wrong-story"
published_at: "2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"
modified_at: "2026-11-16T23:19:13+00:00"
url: "https://mediacopilot.ai/why-traffic-is-dead-is-the-wrong-story/"
markdown_url: "https://mediacopilot.ai/why-traffic-is-dead-is-the-wrong-story.md"
excerpt: "Raptive's Sharon Profis says the data across 7,000 sites is messier than the doom, and the winners are the most human."
taxonomy_category:
  - "AI media analysis"
taxonomy_post_tag:
  - "GEO"
  - "publishers"
  - "google"
  - "video"
  - "traffic"
  - "trust"
  - "media"
  - "AI Overviews"
  - "AI media"
  - "AI search"
  - "Raptive"
  - "Sharon Profis"
---

# Why “traffic is dead” is the wrong story

Raptive’s Sharon Profis says the data across 7,000 sites is messier than the doom, and the winners are the most human.

If you work in digital media, you’ve probably said “Google zero” in a meeting this year. The idea is simple and scary: AI Overviews and chatbots answer the question, nobody clicks, and the traffic that built the open web dries up. There’s real evidence behind it. Plenty of publishers have watched their search referrals fall off a cliff.

Sharon Profis thinks the story is too tidy. As SVP of Audience Strategy and Growth at Raptive, she sees traffic data across more than 7,000 publisher and creator sites, and what she sees is uneven, with real losers and some real winners. On the latest episode of The Media Copilot podcast, I asked her what the doom story gets wrong.

**Listen or watch:**

- [Watch on YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=60kaPu8NTXI)
- [Listen on Spotify](https://open.spotify.com/show/3UAlPpLmb9GXpdmXMIVTDd)
- [Listen on Apple Podcasts](https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-media-copilot/id1712909951)

### Softer, not dead

Search traffic is generally softer year over year, Sharon told me. Most publishers already know that. But the picture changes a lot by category. Some publishers are getting hit hard, and others are growing. Sports, for example, grew its Google search traffic this year, much of it thanks to the World Cup.

The category feeling the most pressure is food. Google has always given recipes special treatment on the results page, and AI Overviews have spread faster across food searches than anywhere else Raptive tracks. At the same time, Google is pulling more short videos and social posts into those results. And a lot of recipe searching now starts on Instagram and TikTok before it ever reaches Google, especially for younger users.

So what’s a creator supposed to do? Sharon’s answer was blunt: be everywhere, and make sure the work you put into social points back to what you own.

### The AI citation paradox

This was the part of the conversation I found most useful, since it touches the GEO work I do. Raptive looked at which sites get cited by LLMs, and found that the stronger a site’s organic Google traffic, the more often it shows up in AI answers. The things that help you rank (unique, timely, high-quality content on topics your audience cares about) are the same things that get you cited.

Meanwhile, for most publishers in Raptive’s network, referrals from LLMs are under 1% of traffic. “That’s not really the point right now,” she said.

I put it to her this way: maybe AI works less as a discovery platform that sends you people and more as a lagging indicator, a sign you’re already running a good operation. “Based on today’s model, a hundred percent,” she said.

That’s a useful corrective for anyone tempted to pull resources away from what works today to chase visibility in chatbots. Getting cited is nice. It doesn’t pay the bills yet.

- Subscribe to our newsletter How AI is changing media, journalism, and content creation. [Learn More](https://mediacopilot.ai/newsletter/)

![Image](https://mediacopilot.ai/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/ads-1024x682.jpg)

### Proof of life

If AI-generated content is about to become abundant and cheap, what’s scarce? People. Raptive surveyed consumers about trust in AI answers, and Sharon said only about 40% trusted an answer with no source shown, while trust rose to 75% when the answer came from a creator or expert they knew.

Her prescription is what she calls “proof of life.” Show your process. Put a person on camera. And if you haven’t invested in video yet, start, because she considers it the best way to stand out from AI right now. As she put it, there are nuances and details “that only a human can show.”

### What CNET taught the industry

Sharon was running content at CNET Studios when CNET’s AI-written articles became a cautionary tale for the whole industry. I asked what she took from it. Her answer was about pace: take a calculated approach, decide clearly where AI fits and where your boundaries are, and revisit those boundaries as you go. Hand AI the operational work, but hold on to the parts of your content where the human imprint matters.

That might be the most useful filter for any publisher right now. If AI is letting you do more of the work your audience values, it’s probably good. If it’s replacing that work, it’s probably not.

**This episode is sponsored by Genna and Yoast.** [Genna](https://genna.com/?utm_source=mediacopilot&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=mediacopilot_nov26)
 turns written content, interviews and recordings into publish-ready video in minutes using real, licensed footage. Yoast SEO AI+ shows how ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity talk about your brand; [join the Yoast Black Friday waitlist](https://yoast.com/black-friday?utm_source=https%3A%2F%2Fmediacopilot.ai%2F&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=media-copilot-promo)
.

### In this episode

Pete and Sharon discuss:

- The nuance behind “Google zero”
- How fast search traffic is changing
- Why food is where AI Overviews hit hardest
- Search starts on social now
- Where creators should focus
- Google’s results page fills up with social
- Recipes, chatbots and the shifting user path
- Multimodal discovery and the return to trusted sources
- The backlash against AI content, and Raptive’s AI trust survey
- “Proof of life” and why video matters
- Google rankings and LLM citations go together
- AI as a lagging indicator
- How creators should use AI in their operations
- One story, many versions
- Lessons from CNET’s AI stories
- What the next few years look like

### About the guest

**Sharon Profis** is SVP of Audience Strategy and Growth at [Raptive](https://raptive.com)
. She was previously VP of Content at CNET Studios.

**About the show:** To explore more conversations like this and see what’s new, visit the Media Copilot website at [mediacopilot.ai](https://mediacopilot.ai)
. You’ll find new episodes, expanded resources, and tools designed for journalists, communicators, and media leaders working through the fast-changing world of AI. It’s the home base for everything Media Copilot and it’s just getting started.

**Enjoyed this episode?** Subscribe to The Media Copilot on [Substack](https://mediacopilot.substack.com/)
, [Apple Podcasts](https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-media-copilot/id1712909951)
, [Spotify](https://open.spotify.com/show/3UAlPpLmb9GXpdmXMIVTDd)
, or your favorite app. On YouTube? Tap the Like button and Subscribe to the [YouTube channel](https://www.youtube.com/@themediacopilot)
.

Produced by The Media Copilot.

Music: “Favorite” by Alexander Nakarada, licensed under CC BY 4.0

All rights reserved. © AnyWho Media 2026

## TRANSCRIPT

**[0:02] Pete Pachal**

Hello and welcome to the Media Copilot. If you work anywhere near digital publishing, you’ve heard the term Google Zero. Because search traffic is shrinking rapidly, and those AI overviews answer questions before anyone can click, a lot of people have decided that the traffic era is simply over. The data is actually more complicated than that, and that’s what we’re getting into today. My guest is Sharon Profis, senior VP of Audience Strategy at Raptive, which runs ads for more than 7,000 independent sites. A lot of them in Food and Lifestyle, which is exactly where AI overviews hit hardest. Before Raptive, Sharon ran content at CNET Studios, and she’s spent more than a decade hosting a cooking segment on PBS, so she’s seen this from the creator side too. Sharon’s take is that the traffic is dead story is more dramatic than data. Some categories are actually growing, while food, where AI overviews have spread fastest, is taking the biggest hit. She also has a counterintuitive view of AI search. Publishers that chatbots tend to cite tend to be the ones already doing well in Google, which makes AI visibility more of a reward for good work than a source of new traffic. And since she was running content at CNET when those AI-written articles caused a stir, I had to ask her what she took away from that. A quick note: if you’re listening on Apple or Spotify, it’d be great if you could leave a rating or review. And if you’re watching on YouTube, please like the video and subscribe to the channel. Those are those buttons down there. Those things really do help more people find the show. All right, now let’s get going with my conversation with Sharon Profis.

**[3:10] Pete Pachal**

Sharon, welcome to the Media Copilot.

**[3:13] Sharon Profis**

Thank you for having me.

**[3:15] Pete Pachal**

Awesome. Thanks for being here. So I appreciate that you have been very vocal lately about what AI is doing to traffic and certainly from your vantage point at Raptive. you’ve probably been seeing that for a little while. I know you went on my friend Brian Morrissey’s podcast recently to add a little nuance to the whole idea of like Google Zero and that traffic is dead. Can you tell me a little bit more about like what what that nuance is exactly?

**[3:46] Sharon Profis**

Yeah, so we we love platitudes, right? in this space. And so saying Google Zero and the traffic is dead and the open web is, you know, in in a downward spiral is more dramatic than what the reality actually shows us, especially in the data. So sure, search traffic is generally softer year over year. I think most publishers are seeing this. and and definitely when you look at the macro, but

What we see in our data and Raptive is a network of more than 7,000 sites and across all kinds of verticals. So we get a lot of really interesting tidbits and slices of the data. And what we see there is that the story isn’t the same for all publishers. Certainly some publishers are hit harder by search traffic trend changes, and others are actually growing year over year.

Depending on the category, we’ve actually we have seen some growth. I think one pretty straightforward example that shouldn’t surprise most people is that the sports category grew quite a bit this year in Google search traffic. And that’s largely because of the World Cup. it’s not only because of the World Cup, but we did see a lot of attribution to that event specifically. So this is this is definitely human traffic. We work.

**[5:05] Pete Pachal**

And this is definitely human traffic.

**[5:11] Sharon Profis**

Very hard, again, just like most publishers, to clean out all of that bot data and and this is real human traffic.

**[5:18] Pete Pachal**

Nice. So tell t tell me give me more texture than that, other than the the sports sort of subcategory. And and can you give me some like idea of the velocity of this too? Because you know the Google Zero thing has been batted around for like a few years. are you seeing like it’s basically still the same rate? Is it accelerating? Is it decelerating?

Do we see some sort of flat plateau in the near or mid midterm future?

**[5:56] Sharon Profis**

Th this is the question that we we try to answer every day. And to add more texture and explain a little bit more of that that velocity or even concentration, I think the best example is probably a vertical that has seen the the greatest impact from Google search features and and the changes that have been rolled out this year and and last year. So the food topic.

has always gotten special attention from the SERP, the search engine results page, from Google, right? Like recipe carousels, those cards that show up at the top of search results for a recipe, those are certainly not new, and those have actually served the category very, very well. they provide people with a really visual way to explore recipes, and Google’s right, like food is a visual.

Topic, and so that’s the right kind of experience to surface. last year we started to notice a growth in the number of AI overviews appearing on food results specifically. We we track this for all categories, but food is where we’ve seen the the most dramatic growth in AIO coverage on the keywords that we track. And it makes sense. Like, you know, the this.

Google is grappling with a pretty complex landscape and change very dramatically changing user behavior. So, you know, in my role and in the history of my career, I’ve always thought about things from a user behavior perspective. And so if we if we back up just a moment and think about how has user behavior changed, and not just over the past year, but over the past several years, maybe even five.

The way that people search for content is extremely scattered. And yes, Google continues to be a primary channel for searching for, again, we’re going with this food example recipes. and we know that based on Google search volume and trends in the food category, that actually food searches have grown. Now, back to the behavior, some of what’s happening is that users are actually going to

**[8:18] Sharon Profis**

social platforms first. And depending on the age group or the generation, that can be much more of a of a higher it’s a much higher figure, especially for Gen Z, but certainly also a growing figure in the in the millennial age group. And so

**[8:35] Pete Pachal**

Yeah, I’ve definitely got a folder of TikTok recipes that I’ll never do, but they’re there. But I said definitely feel that.

**[8:39] Sharon Profis**

No.

Yep, we all have like aspirational screenshots and saves on these platforms. And because the results on the platforms, especially today, like Meta has invested pretty heavily in search on its on Instagram. especially today, those results results are so satisfying. They’re visual, and now for better or for worse, mm depending on how you look at it, if you’re a publisher, possibly for worse, meta is layering its own AI.

summaries at the top of these Instagram results. and so more users are becoming accustomed to going and looking for the creators and publishers content on the platforms where they’re spending more and more time. So that’s that’s Instagram and and TikTok I would include in that of course as well.

**[9:27] Pete Pachal**

So what’s what’s the upshot if you’re a creator though? That when wh where are you concentrating your fire? Where is the you know, audience relationship? What should you be focusing on?

**[9:35] Sharon Profis**

Yeah, yeah. Well, you know, so so the creators in particular have adapted pretty quickly, and and with the most volume, I would say. And so if you’re a creator, but also like if you’re a publisher, the the the playbook doesn’t change that much. you really do have to be everywhere. And so the

s’ because you want to meet people where they are. And so we work closely with publishers and creators in our network to ensure that the effort that they’re putting into these social platforms to create content, meet users where they are, generate new audience and get them to come back can also connect to the work that they’re doing, of course, on the open web. and so y you know, going all the way back to the the original question here about what’s happening.

In Google search and where we’re seeing the most velocity. What’s interesting is that even though we’ve seen such a dramatic increase in AIO coverage on Google search pages in the food category, we’ve also seen Google experiment with some new features that could be hard to measure because we Google doesn’t provide all the best measurement tools just yet. we yep. we could see

**[10:58] Pete Pachal**

Yeah, notice.

**[11:02] Sharon Profis**

so all of these efforts start to converge on the results page. So you’re not only seeing AI overviews and recipe carousels, but you’re also seeing short videos. And these short videos are pulled from platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube Shorts. And you’re seeing the perspectives or what people are saying. And those are often pulled from social platforms as well. and so you know, again, because of the lack of measurement and specificity in the measurement, there it’s it’s not

it’s not easy today to isolate how much AI overviews have impacted the food category. And we see some fluctuation as well as Google plays around with these features on the page.

**[11:42] Pete Pachal**

So we’ve been talking a lot about AI overviews, which obviously that’s a major AI portal. to what extent like does that carry over to Chat GPT and and every Gemini, whatever, like the chat services? Cause I’m just sort of as you were talking there, I was thinking about like what I sometimes do. And again, I’m a sample size of one, so let’s not over overestimate it. But it’s like for various kind of recipes, I’ll sometimes just go right to a conversation.

As opposed to a search, ’cause I already kind of know what I’m sorta doing at least. And then it’s it’s I think what they sort of say is this is kind of like a low stakes, you know, thing, ’cause it’s a recipe. I mean, you know, you could argue maybe not, but it’s not it’s not the same thing as like my health, for example, or or some kind of legal issue I might have where I’d want to go to the source. So often I just it it stops at the conversation. you know, and so is that and I sort of think about this and then you know, not to

Not not to sort of expand this. I’m just we’re not just nerding out about food stuff. I think about how that behavior change can affect whole categories, right? So thinking specifically about well, it’s actually more generally about affiliate type content that is now like it it there’s less incentive for bigger publishers to do it. You know, we’ve certainly seen sort of a shakeout in that category.

based on a behavior change. So so do does the behavior change like toward chat the texture in terms of which categories, like is this affecting food and others? it’s in such a way that it like it might be some people might even like there might be a shakeout in some of these categories. I don’t know.

**[13:30] Sharon Profis**

Yeah, I I I think that there like to your point that yes, people are searching for all kinds of things on, you know, chat, whether in chat or Clot or whatever you use, maybe you even use MetaMuse. whether it’s recipes or who won the game yesterday. that’s probably honestly like the worst use case of that. That’s a terrible example. you know, a travel itineraries. That that is a common use case. So we are seeing I

I don’t know if I pressure might

**[14:01] Pete Pachal**

It’s kind of like one level down from the discovery phase is because of what I’m saying. Like I’m not just going out and broadly like I need recipes for this thing. It’s like I kind of already am zeroing in on something. And I think this is transferable to travel, as you said, and and various other categories. And when I think about, you know, you know, brands have this issue too, and like where in the conversation is the conversion? You know what I mean? And and how does that change between chat, between Google?

and between like things like social. like and also is the proportion between those things changing. Obviously it is because AI wasn’t there before. But, you know, this is kind of what I’m getting at.

**[14:40] Sharon Profis**

It is such a good question and and something that I grapple with too. It and I think that just because of, you know, necess necessary privacy laws and so forth, it’s harder and harder to track these holistic user journeys. But what we see in studies and even in our own observed human behavior is that it’s exactly what you’re saying. It’s multimodal. Like you you you go to Instagram.

**[15:03] Sharon Profis**

And you get influenced to travel to book a trip to Malta or buy those pants. And maybe the browser within Instagram doesn’t ever take you there, or maybe that’s just enough to get you to go search on Google or start a conversation with Chat GPT. But what we do find is that the that users are increasingly, we see this in the data in our network with direct and email and even social referrals, like.

Going back to the publishers and creators that they trust. And I do think that more of these user journeys will be disintermediated by LLMs, where like you’re like, you know what, for this one, I’ll I’ll trust chat for it. You know, I’m gonna go buy those double-A batteries from Costco or whatever. But but for something that where it is higher stakes, and for some people, like cooking a recipe is kind of higher stakes, you’re gonna buy all this.

**[15:37] Pete Pachal**

Hmm.

**[15:59] Sharon Profis**

br bread flour or you know, you know, the all these ingredients, like that’s time, that’s money, that’s effort. ex perfect pretty high stakes. You want to impress your family. So you know when when it’s a higher stakes situation, I I I I believe and when you let’s add a little bit more nuance to this picture. When you add in the increasing volume of AI generated content

**[16:05] Pete Pachal**

Right. Well this is publishing the week before Thanksgiving, so that’s that’s pretty high stakes.

**[16:30] Sharon Profis**

Not made by humans or vetted after the fact. People will naturally want to go back to the experts and sources that they trust. and I think like that right there is the opportunity that really supersedes the whole question of where are people going and like exactly how and when. And it’s more about like, are you creating content and authority and reliability that people want to come back to?

Again and again when they’re making these decisions.

**[17:01] Pete Pachal**

I love that you’ve that’s a perfect transition to talk about trust because I’d love to get your take on what this broader sort of backlash toward AI, and that has a lot of nuances to it, right? And we’re not going to get into things like data centers or whatever, but there is sort of, I feel like a broader backlash, particularly against AI content, and you know, the slopification of the internet and what this really means for creators, right? Especially ones that do want to at least use AI in their process somehow. But

I guess, you know, that’s my first question is like how how should creators think about that as like how to how to sort of take advantage of it but also take advantage of the opportunity, like this backlash is kind of like of a change represents some changing attitudes. and how do they think about that? and well, let’s start there. Why don’t we start there and then I’ll I’m sure I’ll have follow-ups.

**[17:55] Sharon Profis**

Yeah, it it’s it’s kind of a perfect plug for a study that we just did. to and it was a consumer survey about AI trust. And we found that while it was about forty percent of the respondents trusted an AI answer that had no source shown. So that that goes back to our previous topic, right? Like, okay, fine, I’ll I’ll I’ll buy those batteries. I don’t need the source. that that actually it

Rose to 75%. So 75% of the time users, users trusted the AI answer when it came from a creator or an expert that they knew and trusted. And that rose a couple percentage points more when it came from a trusted publisher or media brand. And so, you know, that therein is like I think really does define the opportunity that you’re citing identifying, which is people want people.

I’ve been I you know, I I worked in in content strategy and and development and production for a long time. And the the thing we always came back to was that l like let’s show the humanity because people want to connect with people. They don’t want to connect with computers or j AI generated content. Sometimes they do, but when they need to make a big decision or feel something or be or want to be influenced as we do, the the best versions of that do come from a human. And so

So before we get to the like operational side of using AI, the biggest opportunity is what I would call proof of life and you know, proof of humanity. And s some publishers and creators do this better than others. And and I think a lot of that for for those who have not yet adapted to showing more of the process behind how you

developed that story or ran that investigation. or answering questions about the story on social right. Like there’s a thousand things that you could pick from that really show show the audience the humanity, but also in turn like develop deeper relationships. Those ones who the the publishers and creators who have have not yet caught up, I I think are just they are embedded in in

**[20:18] Sharon Profis**

in some operational inertia that that where right now it’s like the perfect time to break out of. And it is a little bit I it is a little bit or a lot of bit more effort to do all the things that I described. Show your process, like sometimes that means putting your face on camera and in your videos and sometimes it doesn’t. Sometimes it’s as simple as like start making videos. There are a lot of publishers who have not yet invested in video and video is the

very best way to stand out from AI today. Yes, we see really impressive AI generated video content that looks exactly like an influencer or an expert. but but there are nuances, detail, and real life that only a human can show. And that’s best done through video.

**[21:13] Pete Pachal**

So are the sort of, you know, being cited in AI, like you say, if you have that citation next to something is like people will tend to trust that more, especially if they recognize the name. so that’s great. You can’t take trust to the bank. And, you know, like I always sort of think about this and as as I write about it, as I advise people on it, on you know, that it does the Jerry Seinfeld has this joke, right?

You don’t want to be a host. You don’t want to do a good job as a host because hosting well leads to more hosting. And so that’s the only reward you have. And so it’s kind of like the same thing in AI answers where it’s like, hey, you get more trust and you get cited by AI more. Well, wait a minute. Like what what’s where’s the end game here? Like if I’m more trusted in AI and I do all this work, whether it’s the stuff you’re outlining with video or an AI likes me more, where where’s the business outcome that is good?

And how do you steer people toward it? And it’s obviously goes beyond AI, but how do you think about it?

**[22:16] Sharon Profis**

Yeah, it is w the the the challenge and the opportunity that you just identified with like what is all this attribution doing for creators and publishers, like obviously like that could be a whole three-hour podcast on its own, like lots of litigation, I mean we gotta we got lots of time, but but it is it is a problem.

**[22:34] Pete Pachal**

Hey, what’s we got we got at least another half hour here, so

**[22:41] Sharon Profis**

That needs to be solved. And I think like the the economics of that are I’m optimistic that they will be resolved. I choose optimism in this scenario. But you know, what here’s what we found. in our data, we found that the stronger your Google search referral referrals were to your site, so organic search traffic to your site was, the stronger your LLM.

citations are. And so like we are in a period of time. I think it’s, I think it will change if it’s not already changing, where there’s a correlation between doing well in Google search and being cited in an LOM. And what that means is that the things that publishers should do to rank, which is create unique content.

at at the right time at a high quality level against the right the topics that your audience cares about also helps you in the in lm citations and appearing there. Now in our network it and again for most publishers, LLM referrals are like less than a percent of traffic. That’s that’s not really the point right now. But I think that

Whether we’re talking about social or Google search or email, the this the truth has not changed, which is that the way to be successful and and create a sustainable business in publishing is to invest in high quality, unique content, increasingly with a human at the center of it.

**[24:30] Pete Pachal**

So what I’m hearing a little bit, well correct me if I’m wrong here, because this might be a little bit of an extrapolation of your comment, is that the too many p like it’s not that this is necessarily incorrect, but the idea of like AI is a discovery sent platform that’s gonna send people to you is fundamentally kind of incorrect. What it’s and this is now my read, so correct me if I’m wrong. Maybe better to think of it as a lagging indicator of your success in other areas. So in other words, AI is sort of that extra validation.

That you’re running a good operation, right? Like that it’s like, you’re already doing these great things. LLMs and search engines are now tuned to find people doing great things. So you’re you that what you’re doing over here, whether it’s video, you your site, et cetera, you know, focus on that as your monetization, as your business. And then AI, if it sends you stuff, it’s not gonna be much, but it’s great.

**[25:03] Sharon Profis**

Correct.

**[25:25] Sharon Profis**

It ex based on today’s model, a hundred percent. And what what backs that up even a little bit more from a different angle is we we did a study to understand what the correlation might be between social engagement and Google search. for part of my career I ran the audience development team at

audience team at CNET and like most publishers, it was like, what’s a social team up to? Like what are your KPIs? Are you driving traffic to our site? And and I I’m I’m laughing, but like in kind of a sad way where it’s like a lot of social media if you’re a social media manager listening like right now at a publisher, I feel you. It is we we we do. We love you. and and so so here’s something to to take back.

**[26:14] Pete Pachal**

We love our social media managers out there. Love you guys.

**[26:23] Sharon Profis**

which is the we found that the more social engagement a any given site had, the the more growth in Google referrals, the the more social engagement growth that we saw, the more Google referral growth we saw as well. And those are that’s a correlation that can point to a number of things. It could be like you’re creating really good content that people are engaging with, whether it’s on social or being surfaced by Google.

It could also be something that I’m sure many of us have been paying close attention to, which is that Google is pulling in more social signals and social content, I should say, than ever. So connecting your search, connecting your social accounts in your Google Search Console, surfacing short videos and perspectives, like I mentioned from social in Google search. In part because I believe.

That Google is having, and and the there are there’s there’s likely an analogous challenge on the LLM side, having a harder time identifying what content is worth showing. Because of the the growth in AI generated slop content on the internet, Google needs like more literally social proof to show that, to prove that.

This piece of content is the right thing to show and it has authority behind it and people are interested in it.

**[27:54] Pete Pachal**

And like that’s a good sort of circle back to the sort of slop question in terms of how how publishers and creators should think about AI generated content or just AI in their operations generally. given, you know, I I talked about the backlash, but now we’re we’re actually kind of getting at the bot backlash in the sense of like this is in indicator that you know, maybe Google downranks you or or just if it sees AI generated content.

No, I’ve I’m, you know, very AI forward. I recognize that not all everything AI generated is slop, but I also see how smart enough to know I’m probably the exception to the rule, you know, like I think most folks out there see a hint of an AI tally, whether it’s an image or whatever, and it’s like, just nope, I’m not reading that. so yeah, how how how to think about it on the operational level.

**[28:44] Sharon Profis**

Yeah, on on the operational side, I’ve had many conversations with creators and publishers about how how they’re using AI and their workflows. And it it really runs a gamut. I think the the lowest hanging fruit that is still, I believe, underutilized is simply simply using AI to help you understand what is working on any given platform and helping you create like a content

idea flywheel or like help you get better at understanding which audiences you are actually targeting at what time of day and so forth. So there’s like a lot on the there are a lot of opportunities to use AI to tune what you’re already doing by better understanding the analytics behind what what you’re currently posting. So there’s that. On the complete other side of the spectrum there are there are folks who are using AI to

do that and then turning it into this like multi-part system where it’s like, great, now, like give me the content ideas. I will approve which ones I want to actually produce, and then help me create an outline for those pieces of content. Make sure that you’re cross-referencing these keyword tools to ensure I’m including them. Like you can get quite sophisticated at helping at using AI to scaffold your efforts.

without really ever asking it to create the content for you. Now I think that’s going to change, but but in a in a nuanced way. So for example, we’ve been hearing that Meta will release a prompt-based video editor. They just released edits for desktop, which means you can now edit your Instagram reels and Facebook reels on your desktop, which is honestly the problem they’re solving there is that storage.

was being eaten up by all of these videos on people’s devices. But it may also be the start of this product that I I mean I’ve been looking forward to, which is prompt-based editing. And so I think that right now we’re at a time where if you’re really savvy and excited about this, you can create these multi-part systems where your content is is better and you’re more effective because you’re using AI. But

**[30:38] Pete Pachal**

Right.

**[31:03] Sharon Profis**

very soon, a lot of what you’re already the tools you’re already using will be, of course, fortified with AI and feature AI in a way that makes that work easier regardless.

**[31:14] Pete Pachal**

Yeah, it’s funny. I see exactly what you’re saying. I was just at Adobe’s conference, and they’re I don’t know if you saw the news, but they’re moving to that idea of like you can use your AI, whether it’s Chat GPT, Claude, or something else through MCP, to actually drive your apps, right? To do like professional level editing, which some of us might have been already doing a little bit with some some computer use. But but that idea of democratizing that

that sort of professional level editing and opening it up to folks. to your point, I think that the the storage issue might be the tip of the iceberg. Like I think there’s going to at some point, and probably already might even already be seeing this, it’s getting so easy to create video you know, even when whether it’s clips, whether it’s, you know, short videos, whether it’s even sort of longer form, that it’s people are just gonna start doing like it’s just gonna get crazy.

But from a content perspective, does that it’s not quite slop, right? Because this is all people. It’s all just AI produced. but does does that get cheap? And and certainly we’ll get the point where like the OGs of TikTok will be like, I had to do it when, you know, you need like no tools whatsoever. But you know, the the generational winding aside, I feel like the content issue will will become will become something. But I guess we’ll cross it when we come to it.

**[32:28] Sharon Profis**

Mm.

**[32:38] Sharon Profis**

Yeah, I I think it’s going to be cheap. And what what’s interesting about that from a content strategy perspective, if you square it with the way that the social platforms and their algorithms have evolved, it creates a really low-lift opportunity to target new audiences more than ever before. So so in that so if we weren’t speaking like five

Six years ago, even. the the model for growing on social was like post stuff, tell people to follow you, collect followers, and then you’ll post more things, and those followers will see your content. Well, now we know that reach has decreased dramatically on TikTok, Facebook, and Instagram. And that is it reach to your existing followers. And that’s because these platforms are getting

extremely good at showing exactly the right slice of users the content that they believe will resonate most with them. And so to your point, like as content becomes cheaper and more not only can the same publisher create more content than they ever did before, but more people can create more content, there will be an abundance of you know

matchmaking between content and users. And so this is actually an opportunity because look, if you want to stay in your niche and you’re like, you know exactly what audience you want to go after and you don’t want to break out of it, like that’s a respectable choice. But if you want to attract a new audience, you can easily tweak your content and publish it and not get penalized because your current followers won’t see it.

But you will reach new people through the algorithm.

**[34:33] Pete Pachal**

interesting. And is this you consciously deciding that audience and like re-editing or creating even certain things for them? Like give me break this down a little bit for this is actually a really fascinating idea on the video level. What what would it involve exactly?

**[34:46] Sharon Profis**

Yeah. So imagine you are a publisher. like for example, Gear Patrol, I’m a big fan of Gear Patroller in our network, and you’re putting together a a roundup of the best watches and the best Swiss watches. And you you let’s just get unnecessarily specific. So

**[35:07] Pete Pachal**

wow, okay.

I am.

**[35:14] Sharon Profis**

You could create so you should and could create a reel for that. And perhaps your like flagship reel, the main one is like just more generic, like here are the best watches in 2026. You can create five other versions of that with different hooks and yes, like different edits and maybe a different way that the the reporter shows up in it. the to specifically speak to dads, you know, to specifically speak to

People who are a like passionate watch collectors, you can really, you can actually adjust that content. And I think it’s actually so freeing because when you think when we go back to the open web, and of course, like what I’m not saying is that ultimately all of this creates a halo effect for your site on the open web. but when we go back to the open web, when you publish content there, it’s it you have to make like a really hard choice. You’re like,

Who are we talking to here today in this one article that is not really dynamic, that where we have to choose a headline and try to get the the most people to read this with that headline. And so I think like the the opportunity to create multiple versions of content in a really cheap way across platforms is is probably a little bit overlooked right now, but to everything that you said will be more and more possible.

**[36:39] Pete Pachal**

So love to go in a little bit of a speed round here. so I’m gonna fire off a few. if you had to rank for like say a mid-sized creator or publisher right now, you have email, social, direct, search. How how would you rank those? Where where does their neck what’s the no

**[37:00] Sharon Profis**

So hard. I’m I’m I’m going to rank based on where I think current resources are under allocated. And so that so that so search would be at the bottom because I think a lot of teams are pretty well ro robust there. So I would say

d email, direct, social, and SEO. And there are relationships between those, but yes.

**[37:23] Pete Pachal**

Yeah.

**[37:28] Pete Pachal**

Nice. I’ve deep respect for answering the question. Like that’s that’s awesome. good advice. Okay. Auto DM tools. and and just sort of Instagram email funnel, that kind of tool. Are those durable? Are they a platform dependency? What do you think?

**[37:34] Sharon Profis**

Yeah.

**[37:51] Sharon Profis**

Today they are durable and you better ride that wave while it’s still here because they work so well. highly, highly recommend adopting an auto DM tool no matter what your vertical is.

**[38:04] Pete Pachal**

Nice. All right. What makes content hard for AI to replace? Give me give me one example also.

**[38:11] Sharon Profis**

Real human experiences. Hands on. Hands on. I tried this new product. I went on this trip. I tried, I cooked this recipe, I developed it. AI today cannot do that.

**[38:25] Pete Pachal**

Put put in the time. Yeah, I get it. I won’t I won’t double down on the example because we’ve all seen those. so I know Raptive, they I think you just launched something called Compass, is that right? An MCP connection for people can essentially ask ChatGPT or Claude about their own data. What what do you expect people will do with that?

**[38:49] Sharon Profis**

Make much I mean, the peop creators are and publishers already already make great decisions, but make even more informed decisions about what content to create next.

**[38:59] Pete Pachal**

Nice. I’d like to emerge a little bit from the speed round. Well done, by the way. I’d say four out of four there. or two five, I can’t remember. but I’d love to just ask a little bit about your time at CNET, because I I do know you were actually doing content at CNET Studios when CNET had that sort of AI written stories and sort of there was a bit of a cautionary tale in media. I know it’s a few years old now. not here to like go over all of it, but I’m just curious, like did you

**[39:04] Sharon Profis**

Thank you. Yes.

**[39:28] Pete Pachal**

have a good perspective on that episode. What did you take from it? What do you think the industry should take from it about, you know, using AI and content?

**[39:42] Sharon Profis**

I f I’m I’m I’m going back to that time and

I I think what the whole industry learned is that well, all kinds of things happened as a result of that. So I’ll I’ll I’ll choose one point, which is that it it is okay to take a calculated approach before you dive into anything. And I you know, I think at the today, especially more than ever, AI tools

as we discussed, are abundant. The opportunity to create AI content is extremely cheap and easy. And it is a slippery slope once you get in there, right? Like it’s sometimes sometimes you can, and I’m not necessarily referencing that situation, like not see the forest for the trees once you’re inside of it. And so what I I think anyone can learn from that, but also just based on how

what’s available right now and how things are going is perhaps the best approach is to really like be clear about how you want to use it and where your boundaries are. And very intentionally revisit those as you iterate and decide like, what do I love doing and what do I I, whether it’s a publisher or you as a creator, what do I really value putting into my work and what do I and what am I

Happy to continue doing because I believe that it’s better because I’m hands-on, versus what can I hand off? And I think that what we’re learning increasingly, and especially in terms of what the data is showing, is paying off, is that yes, hand over as much of the operational stuff as you can to AI, and as long as it’s reliable for you. But hold on to the areas of your content creation, especially.

**[41:44] Sharon Profis**

Where having that human imprint is very clear. And I think that’s that’s the best case for not handing over all content to creation, content creation to AI, and actually leaning even deeper into human connection with your content.

**[42:01] Pete Pachal**

Nice. It’s a good perspective, good litmus test too. so let’s look out to the future. we’ve done the past just now. We’re gonna look out forward. I want to understand what you think the industry looks like two years from now, five years from now. And really while you’re thinking about that, think about tell me like what what is keeping you up at night? Like what would be ooh, this is we gotta guard against this, and and what are you hopeful about? What are you what what’s a a good sort of almost utopian vision of of where things are going?

**[42:16] Sharon Profis**

God.

**[42:30] Sharon Profis**

Pete, I don’t even know what next month is going to look like. I I really you know, I’ve I’ve actually thought about answering this question. I’m like, I got I who knows? Like a y a year ago things looked so different. And I and yes, we could have predicted some things, but I I think like maybe then the point is we really do have to take things a day at a time and and yes, plan, but most importantly be flexible and

And I know that’s hard, but but I also believe that in some ironic ways, like AI can help us be more and more flexible than ever. I am you know, I am pretty hopeful and optimistic that

That human connection, I know I’ve said this a lot today, but human connection becomes more important because people just crave it more. I I think like the pendulum swings here and the pendulum swings there. And while everyone’s like vibe coding and becoming best friends with their chat bot, I think that there will also be this like growing craving to connect with real people.

And yes, that can be in a social platform in a really well-written article. And so I I don’t buy the doom and gloom that like we’re all just everything is orboros and we’re all going to be reading AI generated content. because I I see just how important it is and I see how much people still do connect with it. just to be exhaustive, what keeps me up at night?

**[44:15] Sharon Profis**

man, I you know, things I don’t know if things really keep me up at night, but things that I’m thinking about or contemplating is with so much with so much demand on publishers to create really excellent standout content on in email, on social, video, and still on your site, like it is it is an expensive endeavor.

And so I do continue to wonder, and it’s really, you know, maybe some of it is that question you asked, like, how can publishers and creators be more operationally efficient so that they can continue to reach audiences no matter where they are?

**[44:57] Pete Pachal**

Nice. I think that’s that’s a good balance view. and I to very much appreciate the the human connection and as as something we’d aspire to and also kind of a litmus test, like we were saying, on like what you’re doing. is it enhancing, is it letting you do more of what you want to do and connect with audiences more? It’s probably good. And if it isn’t, it’s probably not so good. Sharon Profis, thanks so much for stopping by the Media Copilot and sharing all your thoughts with us.

**[45:20] Sharon Profis**

That’s right.

**[45:26] Sharon Profis**

Thank you so much for having me. We didn’t even get to talk about your background as a as in the tech space either. So we’ll get to that next time.

**[45:32] Pete Pachal**

okay. Well that we’ll we’ll have to have you back and we’ll have a little tete tete. All right, take care.

**[45:36] Sharon Profis**

It’s a plan. You too.

**[45:39] Pete Pachal**

Thanks for listening to my conversation with Sharon Profis, SVP of Audience Strategy at Raptive. Please follow or subscribe to the Media Copilot Podcast wherever you’re listening to us. On Apple or Spotify, please also leave a rating or review. And on YouTube, please like the video and subscribe to the channel. The Media Copilot is also a newsletter and a consultancy. You can subscribe to our newsletter at MediaCopilot.ai and feel free to ask about how we might be able to help train your team. Thanks again for being here. Be seeing you in the future.

Contributors

- [The Copilot](https://mediacopilot.ai/author/thecopilot/) : AuthorI'm a generative AI writer for The Media Copilot. I help author posts, and with the help of human editors, play a growing role in the site's content strategy.

Category: [AI media analysis](https://mediacopilot.ai/category/ai-media-analysis/)
Tags:[trust](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/trust/)
| [GEO](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/geo/)
| [publishers](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/publishers/)
| [google](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/google/)
| [video](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/video/)
| [traffic](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/traffic/)
| [media](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/media/)
| [AI Overviews](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/ai-overviews/)
| [AI media](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/ai-media/)
| [AI search](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/ai-search/)
| [Raptive](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/raptive/)
| [Sharon Profis](https://mediacopilot.ai/tag/sharon-profis/)

Share this post:

[Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://mediacopilot.ai/why-traffic-is-dead-is-the-wrong-story/&display=popup&ref=plugin&src=share_button)
[Tweet](https://twitter.com/share?url=https://mediacopilot.ai/why-traffic-is-dead-is-the-wrong-story/&text=Why%20%E2%80%9Ctraffic%20is%20dead%E2%80%9D%20is%20the%20wrong%20story)
[LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://mediacopilot.ai/why-traffic-is-dead-is-the-wrong-story/)
[Email](/cdn-cgi/l/email-protection#7f400c0a1d151a1c0b4226100a0d5a4d4f190d161a111b5a4d4f171e0c5a4d4f0c171e0d1a1b5a4d4f1e115a4d4f1e0d0b161c131a5a4d4f08160b175a4d4f06100a51595c4f4c47441d101b06422817065a4d4f5a3a4d5a474f5a463c0b0d1e1919161c5a4d4f160c5a4d4f1b1a1e1b5a3a4d5a474f5a463b5a4d4f160c5a4d4f0b171a5a4d4f080d1011185a4d4f0c0b100d065a4f3b5a4f3e170b0b0f0c5a4c3e5a4d395a4d39121a1b161e1c100f1613100b511e165a4d39081706520b0d1e1919161c52160c521b1a1e1b52160c520b171a52080d101118520c0b100d065a4d395a4f3b5a4f3e)
