A newspaper unionized because McClatchy put reporters’ names on AI content

The Centre Daily Times in State College, PA, has voted to unionize after months of pushback against its parent company’s AI tool—a move that, according to The NewsGuild-CWA, makes it the first newsroom in the union to cite AI adoption concerns as a primary reason for organizing.

As Nieman Lab reported, the Centre Daily Times staff voted to join The NewsGuild of Greater Philadelphia last month. All eligible editorial staff signed authorization cards, and McClatchy voluntarily recognized the union. The catalyst, reporters told Nieman Lab, was McClatchy’s Content Scaling Agent (CSA) tool—an AI system that repackages existing articles into short-form summaries for publication or video scripts—and a March internal meeting where Kathy Vetter, McClatchy’s chief of staff for local news, told staff the company would use their bylines on AI-generated content unless union contracts prohibited it.

Josh Moyer, a senior reporter at the Centre Daily Times, took that as a signal. “It was essentially like, if you’re not in a union, your byline gets used; if you are in a union, we’ll follow what the union says,” Moyer told Nieman Lab. “If we want to control what happens to our byline, that’s the company telling us that we need to form a union.”

McClatchy introduced the CSA tool at the paper earlier this year. Reporters initially published at least one CSA-assisted story per week under a generic byline noting AI assistance. But in late February, management changed the policy: AI-generated content would now carry the reporter’s actual name. Reporters objected that it misrepresented their work to readers.

“When our names go on a thing, it says that this article or video is from that person, but that is just not true in this case,” said Trebor Maitin, a service reporter. Maitin was the first reporter at the paper to have his byline changed to reflect AI assistance.

The NewsGuild-CWA’s president, Jon Schleuss, said unionized newsrooms have had more success keeping AI content clearly labeled: “Unionized newsrooms are the ones where McClatchy’s AI slop gets a clear label. In non-union newsrooms, the AI slop may be carrying a real human reporter’s byline.”

Multiple McClatchy publications have seen byline strikes over the CSA tool, and some have taken labor actions over the tool and related workplace issues. For the Centre Daily Times, the union opens the door to formal collective bargaining and the ability to join coordinated actions at sister publications.

“Some of us use AI a lot more and are okay with it,” Maitin said. “But there is an overall understanding that we need to be able to have a say in this, and that unionizing at least gives us a seat at the table.”