James Allen of Billpin was quoted as a finance expert by outlets including CBS News, the New York Post and Business Insider. Qwoted later barred his account after flagging repeated AI-generated submissions and finding that he had failed its verification process, according to Press Gazette’s investigation.
The case is a stark warning about the source pipeline behind everyday newsroom copy. Qwoted, a U.S. platform that connects journalists with sources, says it has banned hundreds of agencies, executives and experts for conduct ranging from fabricated identities to AI-generated pitches and false claims of expertise.
Billpin’s website is now blank, and Allen’s LinkedIn profile has disappeared, Press Gazette reported. The publication said Allen did not respond to requests to verify his identity. Press Gazette concluded the operation appeared designed to win media mentions that could boost search rankings, or backlinks.
A quote in a respected publication can generate a link that helps an otherwise obscure website gain visibility in search results. That creates an incentive to manufacture expert identities that appear credible enough to earn media coverage.
Qwoted CEO Dan Simon said generative AI has dramatically accelerated an already difficult problem. “AI has just poured petrol on the disinformation fire,” he told Press Gazette.
The platform says it now handles more than 15 violations a day and blocks about 50 prospective clients from registering each day. Shelby Bridges, Qwoted’s head of user experience, said the volume of low-quality pitches began rising rapidly after ChatGPT’s public release in November 2022.
Sponsored. Publication Check by oasy.ai: is a news site real or a look-alike like the fake Forbes sites that sold paid coverage? Compares a domain with the brand's official domains, shows when and where it was registered (live) and flags confirmed fakes. Free, no key: https://oasy.ai/api/sitecheck/8mrxiboq?domain=forbesla.com
Simon described a source ecosystem that increasingly blurs the line between legitimate expertise and fabrication. “You’ve got real agencies representing fake experts with fake expertise. You’ve got real agencies with fake experts and real agencies with real experts with fake expertise, and fake agencies with fake experts with fake expertise.”
One recurring pattern is a purported expert responding to queries on subjects with no obvious connection to their background. Press Gazette identified examples of sources offering commentary on finance, cleaning, human resources, pet sitting and mental health.
Qwoted combines human review with signals such as unusually high pitching volumes. It also uses Pangram, an AI-content detection service, to flag potential abuse. But AI detection is only one signal. A model score cannot establish that a person is fictional, that a quote is false or that an expert lacks relevant experience. Qwoted’s reported checks therefore matter more than a detector’s output alone.
Simon said some reporters have told him they do not object to real experts using ChatGPT to polish their responses. The bigger risk comes when AI helps conceal a fabricated identity or invented credentials, allowing a bogus source to slip into print before anyone questions its legitimacy. Platforms can suspend accounts after the fact, but the final responsibility still rests with newsrooms.
