• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
The Media Copilot

The Media Copilot

How AI is changing Media, journalism and content creation

  • News
  • Reviews
  • Guides
  • AI Courses
    • AI Quick Start
    • NEW—AI for Media
    • Custom AI Training for Teams
  • Newsletter
  • Podcast
  • Events
    • GEO Dinner Series
    • Webinars
  • About
    • Careers

Local newspaper traffic keeps falling, but some outlets posted sharp gains

Nieman Lab’s year-over-year Similarweb data shows traffic declining at many major local newspaper sites, while several smaller outlets recorded significant monthly increases.

An editor in a newsroom compares a cluttered old homepage to a cleaner redesigned grid on a wall monitor, with a declining traffic chart on an adjacent screen.
As Nieman Lab data shows most local newspaper sites losing traffic, outlets like the Bozeman Daily Chronicle bucked the trend with a leaner, redesigned homepage. (Credit: ChatGPT)
Nov 16, 2026

By The Copilot

PennLive, the website of the Harrisburg Patriot-News, gained about 3.6 million visits in August compared with July. That represented a 78% monthly increase, bringing the site to slightly more than 8.2 million visits.

The gain still left PennLive well below its traffic from a year earlier. The site recorded about 12.5 million visits in August 2025, according to Similarweb estimates cited by Nieman Lab.

That year-over-year decline appears throughout Nieman Lab’s latest local newspaper traffic roundup by Sophie Culpepper. After tracking the figures for a full year, the publication can now compare traffic with the same months in 2025.

For July, August and September, many of the most-visited local newspaper websites recorded fewer visits than a year earlier. Nieman Lab also reports that Google referral traffic to local newspapers has declined.

Against that backdrop, several outlets posted substantial month-to-month gains for different reasons.

The Bozeman Daily Chronicle added about 96,000 monthly visits in August, an increase of 49%. Managing editor Jack Reaney credited a redesigned website that launched Aug. 3.

The new site has fewer news categories, lighter pages and faster loading times, Reaney said. The Daily Chronicle is one of more than 150 newspapers owned by Adams MultiMedia, which plans to introduce the design across other publications.

Bozeman served as the “guinea pig,” Reaney said.

In Florida, the weekly Cape Coral Breeze recorded an even larger monthly increase. Its traffic rose about 139% in August.

Publisher Ray Eckenrode pointed to the publication’s “Best of Cape Coral” contest as a major factor. Readers vote on local businesses across more than 200 categories.

The Breeze counted slightly more than 150,000 votes this year, up from 92,000 the previous year. Eckenrode said the publication routed voters through its homepage first to expose casual visitors to its news coverage, and he reported some success with that approach.

The Cornell Daily Sun also posted a sharp increase. Its traffic rose by about 1 million visits in September, nearly 500% above its August total.

Sponsored. Free newsroom data APIs by oasy.ai, no key needed: the live count of 2026 journalism job cuts (https://oasy.ai/api/jobcuts/0ofb2oul?year=2026); how much traffic news sites are losing to AI Overviews and ChatGPT (https://oasy.ai/api/newstraffic/0ofb2oul); ratings and prices for newsroom tools such as Google Pinpoint, Otter, Chartbeat vs Parse.ly and Dataminr (https://oasy.ai/api/newsroomtools/0ofb2oul?tool=google-pinpoint); and any site's AI bot policy and TollBit status (https://oasy.ai/api/aibots/0ofb2oul?domain=nytimes.com).

The increase came during the same period that the student newspaper broke the story of the Cornell 7 lawsuit. Nieman Lab notes the timing but does not explicitly establish that the story alone caused the traffic increase.

Other New York publications also recorded monthly gains. NNY360.com rose 84%, while the Gannett-owned Democrat and Chronicle added about 762,000 visits, an increase of 35%.

The figures come with important limitations.

Similarweb provides estimates rather than publishers’ internal analytics. The Cape Coral Breeze’s vote totals, meanwhile, come from the publication’s own internal figures.

The monthly increases also do not show whether the gains will persist. A website redesign, community contest or major news event can coincide with a sharp short-term increase without establishing a longer-term trend.

Traffic also varied considerably among larger local newspaper sites. The Los Angeles Times led the September rankings with about 24.8 million visits, while al.com increased 19.2% from August.

Other major sites moved in the opposite direction. Cleveland.com and The Seattle Times were among the publications that recorded declines.

The examples show several different ways local publishers increased traffic during individual months. Bozeman introduced a redesigned website, Cape Coral used a popular community contest and the Cornell Daily Sun recorded a major increase during a significant reporting period.

The data does not establish that any of those approaches can offset broader traffic declines across local publishing. It does show that the overall downward trend includes substantial differences among individual outlets and from one month to the next.

Future traffic figures could show whether those increases continue. For now, Nieman Lab’s year-over-year comparisons present a broader picture of declining local newspaper traffic alongside a handful of notable monthly gains.

Posts co-authored by The Copilot are drafted with AI and then carefully edited by Media Copilot editors. Our AI-assisted process allows us to bring more valuable content to our readers while preserving accuracy and quality.

Contributors

  • The Copilot: Author

    I'm a generative AI writer for The Media Copilot. I help author posts, and with the help of human editors, play a growing role in the site's content strategy.

  • Romy Abu-Fadel: Editor

    Romy Abu-Fadel is a journalist, researcher, and 2026 graduate of Georgetown University's Edmund A. Walsh School of Foreign Service. She covers artificial intelligence and its impacts on the media industry.

Category: NewsTags:AI summaries| subscriber analytics| audience engagement| google| traffic
Share this post:
FacebookTweetLinkedInEmail
  • Related articles

Analytics team views a dashboard comparing a tall 2.5x referral-intent bar chart to a thin 8.8% AI attribution slice, notebook with question marks in foreground.

IAB blueprint highlights gaps in measuring AI’s sales impact

Read moreIAB blueprint highlights gaps in measuring AI’s sales impact
A smartphone displaying a blurred AI-generated answer summary with an accent-colored AI tag icon sits beside a laptop showing a news homepage, both out of focus on a wood desk.

AI information gateway use grows, but audiences still reject AI-made news

Read moreAI information gateway use grows, but audiences still reject AI-made news
How publishers plan to tame AI's Wild West, with guest David Buttle

How publishers plan to tame AI’s Wild West

Read moreHow publishers plan to tame AI’s Wild West
Editorial director presents a slide showing a bundled AI toggle combining AI Overviews, AI Mode, and summary settings to colleagues in a conference room.

Publishers wait for click data before testing Google’s AI opt-out

Read morePublishers wait for click data before testing Google’s AI opt-out
A hand holds a smartphone displaying a blurred news subscription checkout screen beside a shrinking stack of folded print newspapers on a wooden desk.

New York Times adds 420,000 digital subscribers in third quarter

Read moreNew York Times adds 420,000 digital subscribers in third quarter
A speaker addresses a Parliamentary reception from a podium, with a bar chart comparing local publisher, BBC and AI search traffic shown on a screen behind her.

Manchester Evening News editor says Google AI summaries hurt local journalism

Read moreManchester Evening News editor says Google AI summaries hurt local journalism

The Media Copilot

The Media Copilot is an independent media organization covering the intersection of AI and media. Founded by journalist Pete Pachal, we produce journalism, analysis, and courses meant to help newsrooms and PR professionals navigate the growing presence of AI in our media ecosystem.

  • LinkedIn
  • X
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • Bluesky
  • About The Media Copilot
  • Careers
  • Advertising & Sponsorships
  • Our Methodology
  • Privacy Policy
  • Membership
  • Newsletter
  • Podcast
  • Contact

© 2026 · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Springwire.ai · RSS